Girl, 16, Was Stabbed to Death in 1985 and Dumped on a Rural Road. Now Police Chief Says Suspect Confessed Decades Ago to Similar Crime
James Kruczek, 61, is facing one count of criminal homicide in the death of 16-year-old Lottie Jo Gunn
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/james-kruczek-lottie-jo-gunn-111726-0f6bb97cd61044bf89529200677174fe.jpg)
Credit: Westmoreland County PA District Attorney’s Office
NEED TO KNOW
- James Kruczek, 61, is facing one count of criminal homicide in the death of 16-year-old Lottie Jo Gunn
- Gunn was found fatally stabbed and dumped on the side of a rural Pennsylvania road in 1985
- Prosecutors said DNA evidence found on the victim’s clothing linked Kruczek to the killing
A Pennsylvania man was arrested in connection with the slaying of a teen runaway who was found stabbed to death and dumped on the side of a rural road in 1985.
James Kruczek, 61, is facing one count of criminal homicide in the death of 16-year-old Lottie Jo Gunn, the Westmoreland County District Attorney’s Office announced on Friday, Nov. 13.
Prosecutors said DNA evidence found on the victim’s clothing linked Kruczek to the killing.
Gunn was found dead along Turner Valley Road in North Huntington Township on May 24, 1985. She sustained multiple injuries including stab wounds in the abdomen area, according to prosecutors.
At a preliminary hearing on Nov. 13, Glassport Police Chief Shawn DeVerse testified that Kruczek — who he knew from high school — confessed to him in the 80s that he killed a girl and disposed of her remains in the same area where Gunn was discovered, CBS News reported.
DeVerse said Kruczek allegedly claimed she tried to “rip him off,” per the outlet.

Credit: Westmoreland County PA District Attorney’s Office
According to prosecutors, Gunn’s clothing was sent to the Pennsylvania State Police Crime Laboratory and a victim’s DNA profile was created.
“Investigators obtained a search warrant for a sample of Kruczek’s DNA and submitted the sample to the lab which returned a match with the DNA found on the victim’s clothing,” a news release states.
“I was shocked. I was speechless,” Gunn’s sister JoDee told the Akron Beacon Journal after the arrest. “I can’t process the different emotions. So much sadness from my dad’s passing. So much happiness from the arrest.”
Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.
According to the Beacon Journal, Kruczek was the son of a former police chief and had been acquitted in the killing of another teen in 1988.
Lottie Jo was a ninth grader at Barberton High School when she disappeared, the outlet reported. She was deemed a runaway since Jan. 6, 1985.
“Lottie Jo’s family waited an excruciating four decades for answers,” Westmoreland County District Attorney Nicole W. Ziccarelli said in a news release. “While her parents are no longer with us to hear those answers, I am proud of the groundwork our detectives poured into this case in an effort to pursue justice.”